Crowd outside the overly packed Town Room (Jim Wald photo)
Tonight in a marathon overly-packed four-hour meeting the Amherst Planning Board heard all the usual complaints about the The Retreat, including traffic congestion, the supposed dangerousness of 10% grade roads (vs 8%), perpendicular parking vs parallel, too much parking (768 spaces for 641 residents) and, as always, the destruction of community in the adjacent historic Cushman Village.
This Preliminary Plan presentation was just a formal starting point for a long involved process that includes every aspect of Amherst town government: Police and Fire Chiefs, DPW, Conservation Commission, Board of Health, Building Commissioner and even the Pioneer Valley Transit Authority.
The developer had requested numerous waivers and modifications to codes -- reductions in lot sizes and increases in maximum road elevations (from 8% to 10%), and a few long dead end cul de sacs -- in order to make a "cluster development" work.
A cluster development allows for denser construction, thereby preserving open space.
The Planning Board "proposed conditions" include: Streetlights at the end of all cul-de-sacs; but the "less dead ends the better", so the board also suggested adding more interconnectedness with other streets to reduce the number of cul de sacs.
Foot traffic was also addressed as the board suggested paved pathways throughout the development with one running outside to the Cushman Store in the village center.
Parking must allow emergency access for police and fire vehicles with islands every 10-15 car lengths. Handicapped spaces must be provided and a plan for snow removal.
"Careful landscaping" that preserves as many trees as possible, but the board also recommended clearing some areas of the woodlands for other recreation/socializing opportunities.
Oddly enough the board thought the developers were providing "too much" parking (1.2 cars per bedroom) and should "come back with less."
The Planning Board also championed the Select Board's concern about future ownership, wishing to avoid what happened at Townhouse Apartments when the complex went condo. The developer was amenable to a deed covenant preventing the units from being sold off piece by piece.
The Retreat will not be a "gated community" as the Planning Board was unanimous in rejecting the idea. The board was also pleased to hear all units would have sprinklers, which are not required but were highly recommended by Amherst Fire Department Assistant Chief Don McKay.
The rejection of a reduction in lot widths from the current 100 feet will have the greatest impact on the overall design. Landmark Properties will return with a "Definitive Plan" that incorporates tonight's suggestions.
If the Planning Board does not approve it, the developer could file a regular subdivision plan that would give them the same number of lots (123) but spread out over the entire 146 acre parcel.
Jon Williams, Athens GA, the face of Landmark Properties (center) flanked by attorneys Peter McConnell (left) Michael Pill (right)
Tried to live Tweet the meeting but hard to perform as a sardine