So what do you really think?

The red hot issue of a sparkling new solar farm on a dreary old abandoned landfill certainly arouses passion and, as such, folks--especially NIMBYs--tend to shoot from the hip...usually folks who are lousy shots to begin with.

And never is it more evident then those hilarious occasions when they accidentally fire off an email to an entire listserve thinking it was a private response to only one individual.

Gavin Andresen had strongly defended the town's wish to enter a contract with Blue Wave Capital to construct a solar farm generating electricity and a cool million per year in payments and savings on land now sitting empty, costing the town tens of thousands per year in maintenance overhead.

Mr. Andresen even had the gall to publish a GIS photo showing one of the prominent NIMBYs who posts sky-is-falling rhetoric has a backyard touching the landfill.
#######################################
From: DBryne@...
To: amhersttownmeeting@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Friday, May 13, 2011 2:17:28 PMGerry:

Is Gavin Andresen an 'inheiritance case? I met him once for a few minutes and he struck me as 'one of those' BY the way the solar thing will be somewhat close to where I live but I am not an abutter or even close. It's just that I no longer trust Musante-Okeffee,et. al. As far as I can tell they're working for Maroulis. The unanimity of the boards is a tad frightening.

Yes it tends to get me down
when I see folks with shirts of Brown.

David
#######################################
Actually Mr. Byrne is fairly close to the old landfill, but considering he paid $359,000 for his unit five years ago and it's currently valued at only $215,300, he probably does not have to worry about a Solar Farm reducing the value any further.

Of course Mother Mary was informed and took down the offending post and even warned not to "reply all" to the original message as that would resend the string with the offending remarks, but I notice Mr. Bryne still did so last night in an attack on the Gateway Project and as a result resent the original ad hominem attack on Mr. Andresen.

Since Gavin also has a blog I'm sure he has thick enough skin to withstand such biting commentary from the peanut gallery. And (Princess) Stephanie O'Keeffe used to have one.


Hi Folks,

I have just been informed that a message was posted to this group that was intended to be a private message. This haas happened to others and can be embarrassing for all involved. Group members are advised that replying to any message from this listserv that has [AmhTownMtg] in the subject line will go the the WHOLE LISTSERV and not just the person who wrote the message you are replying to. Please be careful when replying!

Please DO NOT reply via the group to the message titled "my objection last night" as that might resend the message sent by mistake. Thank you all for your cooperation on this.

Mary Streeter
TM Discussion Group Moderator

How I was banned from the private Town Meeting listserve without really trying

Solar Shoot Out

Today's Amherst Bulletin half-page political ad

Monday's Amherst Town Meeting is shaping up to be an ultra-modern shootout at the OK corral where combatants carry Star Trek phasers instead of six shooters.

NIMBYs fire off a half-page ad selectively quoting from a NIMBY website that selectively cherry picks facts from oceans of Department of Environmental Protection required data, but still doesn't endorse the expensive sky-is-falling ad; and the town quickly (and cheaply) responds with a full spread of photon torpedoes via the main page of the official town website, normally a place where people go to figure out how to pay parking tickets.

While the old unlined landfill these folks bought expensive homes around certainly does produce lots of leachate--especially when it rains--that fluid is not exactly a toxic green goo oozing towards the town water supply. If you try to reuse a teabag for your fifth cup of tea, the results will be mighty disappointing.

All the groundwater monitor wells (28) around the old landfill fail to show contamination beyond a few chemicals and even then only in traces and it flows in the opposite direction from the municipal water supply over a mile away. Plus the methane/sulfur gas detectors (9) stationed around the perimeter all test completely negative.

In fact, the most recent DEP report to the town (2010) clearly states in bold letters: "Groundwater does not flow towards the Lawrence Swamp public water supply wells, which are located over one mile to the south/southeast." And if that is not clear enough, they boldly sum it up: "The qualitative risk assessment concluded that there were no significant risks to human health or public safety posed by the landfill."

The main reason the town is under orders from the DEP to regrade the cap is because the contents have settled, causing the cap to sag from a lack of support from down below allowing rain water to pool in places. Thus the regrading will help with water runoff and will most certainly aid in reducing leachate production.

But that is not what conflicted neighbors will unleash on Town Meeting Monday night. Instead, a doomsday scenario that could pass for a science fiction disaster movie trailer. YouTube here they come.

Old landfill (note gas detection pipes)

Solar farm moves forward

Despite vocal opposition from immediate neighbors, the Select Board tonight voted unanimously to recommend article #24 to Amherst Town Meeting, a motion that will allow the Town Manager (who is appointed by the Select Board) to enter into a long-term contract with BlueWave Capital for low cost electricity generated by a sea of solar panels placed on the old landfill.

ARTICLE 24. Authorize term of lease for Old Landfill (Planning Board)
To see if the Town will vote to authorize the Town Manager to lease all or any portion of the Old Landfill across Belchertown Road from the existing Transfer Station from time to time by one or more leases for such term of years up to 30 years and for such consideration as the Town Manager shall determine, for the purpose of installing and operating thereon a solar array for electric power generation and distribution, and to authorize the Town Manager to grant such easements in, on, under and across over said land for utility and access purposes, as reasonably necessary to install and operate such a solar array, and further to authorize the Town Manager to enter into a power purchase agreement with any lessee of such property to purchase all or a portion of the electricity production of the solar array and to enter into an agreement with the local utility to participate in the Net Metering program pursuant to the Acts of 2008, c. 169, §78, the so-called Green Communities Act, as may be amended.

What's yours is mine

Trampoline half on town property. Note also cleared, mowed area of encroachment

A couple square yards here and a couple there, pretty soon you're talking football field

No wonder the folks cocooned in high-end houses on Tanglewood Drive are so heated about the town finally getting around to turning the expensive old dump into something productive--a lucrative, environmentally friendly solar farm.

Not only do they now enjoy a great view, but some of the folks have enhanced that view by encroaching on town property.

A backyard view

A tree fort and swing way out on the landfill

Cleared manicured area beyond the property line

Solar powered Electric Chair?

This detonation of a backpack nuke at last night's Select Board meeting--publicly suggesting Amherst will be an "accomplice in a capital crime"--was obviated a couple hours later, when reading from a prepared statement during his Town Manger's report, John Musante informs the Select Board he's given up on using DEP approved contaminated soil to regrade the old unlined landfill.

Still, you gotta love Mr. Boothroyd's borrowing from Steve Jobs the "one last thing" intro before dropping the bombshell.



End result? The town losses $250,000 in disposal fees paid in work/equipment barter from the major contractor rebuilding Atkins Corner, who will now have to pay cash to another disposal facility at a greater rate per ton for the 6,000 ton load.

And the town will have to rely on street sweepings and catch basin crud to try to make up the difference for the regrading but will probably have to bring in clean fill at additional cost in labor and cash. All in all, a lose-lose scenario.

Twenty years ago Mr. Keenan enhanced his "fiscal conservative" image by volunteering to clean up pigeon poop from the Town Hall attic after Town Manager Barry Del Castilho (worried about the health of his secretary, who later became his wife) was preparing to spend over $100,000 to have a hazardous waste disposal company clean it up.

And a couple weeks ago Mr. Keenan blew the whistle to DEP about 20-30 barrels of potentially hazardous waste (paint from UMass) that was buried somewhere in the landfill over 25 years ago by town DPW workers.

But if everyone is also so concerned about the integrity of the landfill cap, then why try to force the town into cracking it open to dig for those 20 or 30 needles in a haystack?

Solar Flare

Atkins construction soil

John Boothroyd and Dave Keenan, two outspoken critics of the town's attempt to recast the old unlined landfill into a sea of shiny solar panels took their battle directly to the Select Board at the unscripted 6:30 PM "Question Period" tonight, focusing on the potential health hazard of pesticide laced soil approved by the DEP as partial fill to repair sagging areas of the landfill cap due to settling common after 20 years of decomposition.

John Musante, during his "Town Manager's Report", told the Select Board the contaminated soil controversy had created "a lot of anxiety" and become a "distraction."

The regrading of the landfill will occur regardless of the solar array project and since the use of lead arsenate soil was a relatively minor part of the overall work, he directed DPW chief Guilford Mooring to abandon the idea of using 6,000 tons of tainted soil from the Atkins Corner Road project, although he praised Mr Mooring for "trying to be entrepreneurial".

Musante by no means backed down on the ambitious project to construct a 4.75 megawatt solar farm on the landfill that could provide the town with a million dollars per year in combined electricity savings and property tax revenues.

Searing the solar farm

Yes this is the same Diana Spurgin who fours years ago was treasurer of the 'Amherst Plan Committee' a band of soccer moms, well paid academics and 'Amherst Center' types pushing a $2.5 million "Three Year Plan" tax Override hatched by our Finance Committee, at the time toothless watchdogs who acted more like lapdogs for town officials.

And of course their main propaganda pitch, as usual, was to shame taxpayers into voting yes for the collective common good especially for the sake of the children, who attend one of the most expensive public school systems in the state.

Ahh, but when it comes to a creating a higher-and-better use for town property, a deal that could benefit the common good by $1 million per year while reducing our carbon footprint, don't disturb the tranquility near my backyard (an unlined landfill).

Today's Sunday Republican reports

Amherst Solar Farm meets Jerry Springer show!

The only thing missing among the crowd who jammed the town's solar farm public forum Wednesday night was bullhorns, pitchforks and torches. Perhaps a better headline would be: "When NIMBYs attack."

Yes amazingly enough these restless natives who purchases expensive homes next to an old unlined landfill are worried a commercial solar array will ruin their property values. After all, real estate agents promised them the landfill would remain open space for 99 years. And if you can't trust real estate agents who can you trust? Used car salesmen perhaps?

The complaints aired ran the typical gambit: noise, visual pollution, losing open space to walk the dog and go sledding, turning the neighborhood into another "Love Canal" and--my favorite--Russia dealing with Chernobyl compared to the way Amherst town government is now going about the process. Yikes!

Kind of far fetched to claim the solar array will cause damage to the landfill cap when DEP will have to approved it after exhaustive study and the expert the town is partnering with, John DeVillars is a former New England Administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

A couple years ago Town Meeting was going to award Guilford Mooring "Mr. Congeniality" for his patient, good natured, humorous way of presenting DPW issues to that legislative body. So for him going Postal, says a lot...

Voter poll on Localocracy (looking like a landslide)

The Daily Collegian reports

Dark clouds on the Solar Farm horizon?

DEP requires Amherst to regrade undulations at old landfill

Dave Keenan, a long-time thorn in town officials side, although once a town official himself, is baaaaaack.

Now he's lobbing a stink bomb into the middle of Amherst public officials picnic over turning our old abandoned landfill into a cash cow solar array farm that will produce enough renewable energy to supply all municipal needs, saving the town almost $1 million per year in electricity costs, and pay up to a couple hundred thousand dollars annually in property taxes.

Government tax incentives have stimulated these sunny public/private partnerships springing up nationwide like weeds after a summer rain. And it's not as though old landfills are good for much else.

Mr Keenan blew the whistle to his old acquaintances at the Department of Environmental Protection claiming three retired DPW workers told him about 20-30 barrels of hazardous wastes--allegedly lead based paint from UMass-- they were ordered to bury back in the 1980s.

While I cannot corroborate that particular story, I can verify first hand that hazardous materials were indeed tossed into the smelly pit. Yes, I admit it; 50 years ago my dad and I threw old paint, solvents, dirty motor oil, leftover cleaning products, insecticides, fertilizers, outdated medicines, etc. As did most of the citizens of bucolic Amherst.

To say there are hazardous wastes buried in the old landfill is like declaring there's bear dung in the woods of Maine. That's why the town spent a considerable amount to cap the site with an impermeable protective cover: to keep water from mixing with the dangerous contents and forming a hazardous cocktail that could could migrate downstream. Monitoring sites were also installed to test for that scenario and a system to handle methane gas.

But after 20 Years of fermentation the contents down under have settled causing the cap to sag in spots, allowing pools of water to form on the surface. The DEP ordered the town to fill in the depressions and regrade the site to its original aircraft carrier flatness--all without disturbing the cap of course. As you can imagine, that is a tad expensive.

Fortunately the town is in the middle of a road construction boom. The Atkins corner project, with two roundabouts coming soon, has already generated massive amounts of dirt. Only one slight problem: 6,000 tons of it is contaminated with lead arsenate, a common insecticide used on apples orchards between 1892 and the early 1970s when it was banned by the EPA.



The contractor can either spend a fortune hauling the contaminated soil to a special handling facility or bring it to the old landfill to use as fill for DEP required site remediation. Everybody saves a ton of money. The DEP approved the idea, but will require a three foot layer of non-polluted soil to cover the contaminated soil and numerous other safety precautions.

But every cloud does indeed have a silver lining. If a project--like the Bluewave Captital Solar panel farm on the old landfill--is "part of a site remediation or restoration under a Mass/DEP enforcement action/order" it is eligible for "fast track status" when negotiating the local permitting process.

And while the long-term contract with Bluewave will have to be approved by town meeting it will only require a simple majority vote, unlike a zoning change that requires two thirds.

Who says money doesn't fall from the sky? Now it will--whenever the sun is shining.



Christmas '07: After the town took Dave Keenan's humble abode for $50,000 in back taxes he camped out in his former front yard. DEP fines for ten years procrastination cleaning up an oil spill also amounted to $30,000. Mr. Keenan eventually repaid Amherst over $63,000 in back taxes and legal fees.

Business West profiles the Amherst Solar farm

Let the sun shine

Ye Old Landfill 1:55 PM

Okay, so unlike his predecessor--that PR challenged guy who flew the coop not too long ago--Town Manager John Musante really gets PR. Although I think he goes a tad overboard with the spin-like intro that Amherst will be a "leader in our region on solar energy," when Athol has beaten us to the punch. Yes, Athol.

But BlueWave Capital is certainly a well-connected, heavy-hitter, as their lead principal John DeVillars is a former environmental affairs secretary for Mike Dukakis who worked his way up to (federal) EPA regional honcho.

And the current Governor seems to be into all things solar and is putting those all important tax credits behind that enthusiasm (at taxpayer expense).


Our modest solar start