The answer to bad speech is more good speech, not censorship
As an unabashed defender of the First Amendment I bristle at even the hint of government intrusion into the marketplace of free ideas, even when those ideas are upsetting or obnoxious.
Speech that makes you comfortable is not what needs protection. And it would be impossible for firebrands like me to "comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable" when my speech is regulated by boorish bureaucrats.
So when more than a few people sent me the link about UMass having a "threat meter" for costumes which would pretty much lead to a bland Halloween -- and I always look forward to scantily clad young women dressed up as Indians, err, Native American -- I took notice.
But I also remembered UMass allowed the nitwit Westboro Baptist Church to freely demonstrated their bigotry on campus a few years ago. So I was also a tad skeptical of this latest brew ha ha -- especially when Campus Reform said they ran with it prior to a UMass spokesperson responding.
My favorite UMass spokesperson, however, did respond.
From: Larry Kelley <amherstac@aol.com>
Sent: Friday, October 21, 2016 8:48 AM
Subject: Halloween
To: Nancy Buffone <buffone@umass.edu>
Hey Nancy,
So I'm always a tad skeptical when these stories first break wondering if perhaps they belong on Snopes.
https://www.campusreform.org/?ID=8272
Is this a University wide program? (I'm surprised there's no mention of clown outfits.)
Is the University taking any special measures for Halloween weekend like limiting guests, parking, etc?
Larry
#####
From: Nancy Buffone <buffone@umass.edu>
To: Larry Kelley <amherstac@aol.com>
Sent: Fri, Oct 21, 2016 10:45 am
Subject: Re: Halloween
Larry,
The campus has been planning for Halloween and has communicated
guest restrictions on the residential halls to our studends. There is
information on line at:
http://www.umass.edu/living/sites/default/files/documents/assignments/homecoming_and_halloween.pdf
As far as the posters go, here's a statement from the News Office:
University of Massachusetts Amherst statement on Halloween costumes
As part of the university’s continuing efforts to foster an
inclusive and supportive living environment for all students, resident
assistants at UMass Amherst this month created bulletin boards
communicating those values and explaining how some Halloween
costumes may be offensive to others. The guidelines used to create the
bulletin boards are intended to educate students about cultural
appropriation and help them make informed choices about costumes. UMass
Amherst does not prohibit or ban any costumes.
In one residence hall, a “threat level flow chart” for choosing a
Halloween costume was posted on a bulletin board. It is not part of the
recommended educational materials that RAs were advised to display, but
rather was downloaded from the Internet and
was posted by a well-intentioned student staff member. The chart has
been removed from the bulletin board.
Thanks,
Nancy
Nancy Buffone
Associate Vice Chancellor for University Relations
Associate Vice Chancellor for University Relations