AG Rebukes Regional School Committee

Maria Geryk (far left) Amherst Regional School Committee to her left

A six-month investigation by the Massachusetts Division of Open Government found the Amherst Regional School Committee did indeed violate the Open Meeting Law at its November 22, 2011 public meeting--but not for the technicalities I cited in my complaint.

At the very end of a three hour Regional School Committee meeting Amherst School Committee (who make up the lions share of the Region) Chair Irv Rhodes moved to go into executive session, "never to return." The motion is never properly seconded and no mention is made of why they are going into executive session other than the brief announcement three hours earlier at the start of the meeting by Regional Chair Rick Hood.

The Attorney General found, "While the Committee announced a valid reason for entering into executive session, the Committee violated the Open Meeting Law by discussing matters in executive session that were not appropriate given the stated purpose."  And the AG points out sternly, "This is not a mere technical violation."

Interestingly the casual indifference to protocol displayed by this nonchalant executive session is consistent with the infraction that got them in trouble with the Attorney General.  In fact, even after I filed my official complaint the arrogant attitude continued as they failed to properly respond to the Attorney General, which is duly noted in this official four page finding.

The Amherst School Committee now has two new members--Amilcar Shabazz and Lawrence O'Brien--and Rick Hood will be stepping down as committee chair later this month, so perhaps things will change.

Adhering to the principles of honest open government helps to build trust.  And trust in your local government is like money, education or good health--you can never have too much of it.

AG Amherst Region Violation
Already having an impact. Most recent agenda posted to town website:

Thursday, June 7

RECEIVED: 6/5/12 at 12:27 pm. MEETING TIME: 4:30 pm. LOCATION: Amherst Regional Middle School, Superintendent's Conference Room. LIST OF TOPICS: Enter Executive Session to discuss strategy sessions in preparation for negotiations with nonunion personnel or to conduct collective bargaining sessions or contract negotiations with nonunion personnel as authorized by MGL Chapter 30A, Section 21(2), with no intention to return to open session.

Ghost Bike in Hamp Center

 Ghost Bike Northampton Center

A ghostly reminder of the  tragic crash that took the life of 18-year-old Harry Delmolino, a Hadley resident, appeared recently at the Pleasant/Main street intersection in the heart of Northampton, only yards from the exact spot where the car/bike collision occurred.  A battle the car always wins.

Ghost bikes are roadside memorials set up near the site of a fatal accident that has claimed the life of a cyclist.  In Amherst a ghost bike appeared on University Drive near the location of the crash that killed Misty Bassi.   Misty was killed on Memorial Day 2009 by a distracted driver on the wrong side of the road.

Another Ghost Bike appeared on Montague Road to commemorate the 9/12/09 hit and run death (never solved) of Blake Goodman.  Amazingly the bike was later vandalized by two young men wielding axes.

Gone Like the Wind

Trolley Station on North Pleasant Street, built 1911 destroyed 5/29/12

So I can't help but wonder if this inappropriate demolition of a historic structure is a reenactment of the murder of Thomas Becket by King Henry's stooges, who thought his highness had officially ordered it.

On Tuesday a construction crew trashed the historic little gem that state officials in Boston wanted to preserve for a while longer but local UMass officials made perfectly clear they wished it gone, gone, gone.

 Gone without a trace

Interestingly, the dirty deed happens soon after thousands of students--potential witnesses-- leave campus and hidden from view by a new fence.  The first time UMass tried to demolish it back in 1994, a faculty member blew the whistle--thus giving the structure a long reprieve.

Coincidentally enough this unauthorized destruction occurs only weeks after Amherst Town Meeting showed strong support for maintaining the integrity of historical structures by overwhelmingly passing the Dickinson Historical District zoning bylaw.

Yes, our local Historical Commission had requested this particular building be preserved but they have no authority over UMass, thus they could not issue a one year demolition delay.  And even if they did issue that official restraining order, this despicable deed was supposedly done independent of owner (UMass) oversight.

Said historic preservation pit bull Joseph Larson, "Contractors can sense this indifference and are more likely to misbehave." Indeed.

Amherst Tastes Just Fine

A banner that makes you hungry hangs over downtown Amherst

So Amherst may have lost a traditional, fun, family-oriented 4th of July Parade that attracted throngs of celebratory people to the downtown, but another quaint tradition is alive and well:  The Taste of Amherst.

Yes, Northampton--a mecca of fine dining--may have given up on the culinary crowd source concept but Amherst is still going strong...20+ years and counting.  This year 23 restaurants will be offering their favorite wares:  great affordable food, served quickly and conveniently on compostable plates.  Sustainable Amherst gets greener by the day.  

In addition to a potpourri of fine foods the Taste also provides that adult favorite, beer.  Local institutions Amherst Brewing Company and Rafters will provide craft brews served by friendly barkeeps.  While WRSI, "The River", will provide music from a remote soundstage with live bands scheduled  throughout the four day event.

Kids will love Magician Fran Ferry (who will conjure up perfect weather) and all the cute critters from the Forest Park Zoo.

Beer, music, food and a boatload of happy people clustered in beautiful downtown Amherst.  I can't think of a better way to spend Father's Day.

Hours for the Taste of Amherst, sponsored by Atkins Farm Country Market, are Thursday, June 14, 5-9pm; Friday, June 15, 5-10pm; Saturday, June 16, 12-10pm; and Sunday, June 17, 12-4pm.

Hazard in the Hole!

Ladder Truck #1 flanked by specialized hazardous response vehicles

Any good successful boxer will verify the importance of proper training; and when your life or the lives of innocent civilians are potentially at stake, training is all the more imperative.

On Wednesday the regional HazMat team met at North Station for their monthly training session where they did a walk through of UMass buildings--Central Heating Plant, labs, etc--and then participated in a simulated event.

Amherst Fire Department has four members who participate in the Western Massachusetts Regional Hazardous Materials Team, including Chief Tim Nelson who is a district team leader.

Fade to Black

Amherst July 4 Parade 2002-2012

They say you don't really appreciate something until it's gone. Especially those service oriented endeavors you learn to rely on as part of a favorite routine--a funky restaurant, a comfortable health club or a one of a kind movie theatre.

Sadly, we will soon find out if a good old fashioned patriotic parade makes your list. Because this July 4th--for the first time in ten years--downtown Amherst will not host an endless line of slow moving firetrucks, police cars, construction trucks, tractors, marching bands, floats, veterans, cheering crowds and more flags than Amherst sees all year.

The last town sponsored July 4 Parade stepped off in 1976. After a 26 year hiatus and as a direct response to the horror of 9/11, Kevin Joy reconstituted a private July 4th Parade Committee to put on a family oriented extravaganza while giving public thanks to our public servants--police, fire, EMT, and military.

And since 2002 the parade committee has done exactly that. But from the very beginning the committee was harassed and bullied by the town because the rules of the parade called for a celebration, not a protest.

In 2008 then town manager Larry Shaffer arbitrarily decided the town would run a 7/4 parade and the private committee would not be issued a permit.  As you can see, I did not take that very well. Neither did the ACLU, and the town quickly backed down.


Last year with a new town manager and normalized Select Board, for the first time in our short history there was no controversy--no mention of anti war protests one way or the other. Like all the previous years, the parade itself went off without a hitch.
So why surrender now?  Costs mainly.   The entire committee donates their labor but the bands,insurance, police, and a dozen other items amounts to serious money.  Plus fundraising is never easy--especially in this economy.

Besides that we're tired.  And now, sorry. So very sorry.

The Springfield Republican reports

####

Sent: Thu, May 31, 2012 9:55 am

Hi Kevin, Helen, Larry and others --

I just wanted to tell you how sorry I was to hear from Scott Merzbach yesterday that the parade won't happen this year.  You all have done such an amazing job with that and made it a special part of the July 4th events.  It's hard to imagine that day without it.  I will miss it, as will so many others, and I hope it can come back next year.

The work it takes to make the parade happen is incredible -- and beyond what most of us probably imagine.  The careful organization of the whole thing, particularly the check-in and set-up by Amherst College, and how smoothly that runs, has always been so impressive to me.  An enormous task that you all made run like clock work!  (Scott's article today is erroneous in suggesting I said it may not be too late for others to put together a similar parade -- I don't think that would even be possible.  My comment about "maybe it's not too late" was my reaction when he told me that you couldn't raise enough money for this year.)   Your attention to the logistics of it all made for such a professional and well-run event.     

Thank you for your work on this for all these years!  It has brought happiness to so many!  

Stephanie O'Keeffe
Chair, Amherst Select Board

Stephanie's dead on observation from four years ago

July 4 Parade Thanks 2005

One last time, into the fray

Shutesbury:  Where the welcome sign is not the only thing frayed

The back-and-forth in the sad saga of the Shutesbury library vote is enough to give an observer whiplash.

With the June 30 deadline looming for the town to accept a $2.1 million state grant, the Supreme Judicial Court last week refused to hear an expedited appeal of Judge Rup's decisive decision to throw out two previously counted yes votes of attorney Michael Pill's grown children thus bringing the (never say) final vote to 522 "no" to 520 "yes" in the $1.4 million override request required to match the state grant.

Originally library proponents had filed suit against the Board of Registrars requesting the court, "Order the defendant Board of Registrars not to count the votes of Richard and Joan Paczkowski, or in the alternative if the Paczkowski votes are to be counted, then order the defendant Board of Registrars to count the vote of Christopher Buck."   Either of those two alternatives would have changed the outcome of the library vote from a failure to passing.

Instead Judge Mary-Lou Rup not only upheld the Board of Registrars decision to allow the challenged Paczkowski votes but then she went a step further and negated the votes of Shoshana Holzberg-Pill, and Jacob Holzberg-Pill.  To date the only negated vote that now seems unchallenged is that of Christopher Buck, who signed a legal document (license) in Kentucky, where he has been  employed full-time for the previous two years, clearly stating Kentucky is his sole legal domicile for voting.

Since town attorney MacNicol is now being so accommodating there's probably enough time for "direct appellate review" by the appeals court of Judge Rup's decision, which most experts believe will be upheld.  By then, however, the June 30 deadline will be at hand and no compromise possible between the opposing sides to get a piece of the $2.1 million state grant.

The picturesque M.N. Spear Memorial Library

The year (1923) Babe Ruth broke the record for all-or-nothing home runs, he also lead the league in strikeouts.  Those who fail to learn from history...